...And they're all for less than £10 too! I've harped on enough about my horrendous dark rings under my eyes and I'm constantly trying out different products to try and hide them as much as possible. These three concealers have cropped up on so many different blogs on numerous occasions and I can totally vouch for the fact that they are worthy of their rave reviews. Whilst each product are very efficient on their own I've found that mixing all three together creates the perfect formula for both brightening and concealing the under eye area.
There's been quite a lot of mixed reviews about this concealer in terms of what it's best used for. Most people seem to love it to cover up blemishes but not so sure about using it beneath the eyes as it can look cakey. I wasn't massively keen on it at first however I could appreciate that it did cover up very well; hence why it's popular for hiding any imperfections. I figured that it could be good for concealing dark rings but I just needed to mix it with something that was more hydrating in order for it to look a lot more natural once blended. This is where Maybelline's Eraser Eye comes in and forms a fab combo...
If you look at the swatches below you'll notice that The Eraser Eye is a lot more sheer in comparison to the other two concealers. My rings are too dark to use this alone however I'm sure that there are some lucky people that can use this as their sole under-eye concealer product (and I'm very jealous!). Despite this, I really do love this concealer as it's super hydrating and leaves a dewy finish to the skin without creasing at all. The sponge applicator is a little unusual but really easy to work with. By combining this with Lasting Perfection I'm getting both of their best qualities in one. I swipe a line of Lasting Perfection along the socket bone and then apply the Eraser Eye over the top and blend outwards. I like to leave it to dry for a couple of minutes before gently patting into the skin. Lasting Perfection conceals the dark rings whilst the Eraser Eye prevents it from looking cakey.
This is the middle man in the sense that it doesn't provide quite as much coverage as Lasting Perfection but more than Eraser Eye, and it isn't qute as hydrating as Eraser Eye but not as cakey as Lasting Perfection. It's kind of an inbetweener yet it is still a great concealer. It literally does 'wake up' the skin by illuminating the area, providing a brightness that isn't quite achievable by using the other two alone. To apply this I use the doe foot applicator to dot along the socket bone over the top of my blended combo (as above). I find that leaving it to set before blending with my fingers creates a slightly thicker consistency and keeps the product in place rather than just dragging it around the skin.
Using three concealers beneath the eyes may seem like a lot of product, especially where the skin is so thin and prone to looking cakey however I only use a very small amount of each to ensure that it still looks very natural.
Currently this little trio has been working an absolute treat for me. Have you tried either three?
love Katya x
Follow me
I've heard such great things about the age rewind! Wish they were available in my country
ReplyDeleteCandice | Beauty Candy Loves
It's so lovely and hydrating. Hopefully it will come to your country soon!
DeleteI've heard great things about the Wake Me Up one! I really have to try it!
ReplyDeleteRenee | Lose The Road
It's such a lovely concealer. It's so brightening and not too heavy!
DeleteI love Collection's concealer. I like wake me up to, but nothing seems to beat collections for me!
ReplyDeletex
a life of a charlotte
Collection is definitely the best out of the three for concealing any darkness!
DeleteI didn't like the Collection concealer as much as everyone else, because I mostly needed for under eye area 7 it can feel too heavy for that. I did quite like the Rimmel Wake Me up one but not sure why I never repurchased x
ReplyDeleteBeauty with charm
It really does have such mixed reviews. I agree it can be a little heavy for such a delicate area but I always ensure I use it sparingly and the Maybellline thins it down.
DeleteI have the Maybelline and Rimmel one and I love them to cover blemishes! I always see that the Collection one is raved about but I can't get a hold of it from where I live, I really want to try it someday. Great review! xo
ReplyDeleteKlaudia // klaudiam96.blogspot.com
Collection is a really great one if you manage to get your hands on it! Thank you!
DeleteThe collection concealer has been my go to for years! I definitely need to mix it up soon and try some of the others featured in this post:)
ReplyDeleteEilidh from Velvet Winter
It's fab isn't it! The other two are brilliant as well, I'd definitely recommend them!
DeleteThis is such a useful post as my concealer just ran out! Will make sure to swatch these ones :) xx
ReplyDeleteChasing Belle 23
Glad I could be of help! I hope you like them. You'll have to let me know your thoughts!
DeleteLove your photos - I've gone through about 6 or 7 of the Rimmel Wake Me Up I just love it, I think I love that its a good happy medium haha!
ReplyDeleteLucy | www.foreverseptemberr.blogspot.co.uk
Ah thank you so much! It's definitely one to repurchase, it literally is such a happy medium. I couldn't agree more!
DeleteI really love Rimmel's Wake Me Up! I really love it, almost as good as my Max Factor one but cheaper xD a lovely post! xx
ReplyDeleteelizabeth | ”Ice Cream” whispers Clara | bloglovin follow for follow
Follow for follow on instagram :D
It's so reasonably priced isn't it! It's great that it can be compared to a more expensive version.
DeleteI quite like the Collection lasting perfection concealer myself, although I think that's a great tip to partner it with the Maybelline offering to make it more hydrating :)
ReplyDeleteVelvet Blush
The two work as a great team! The Maybelline thins the Collection down so it's not too heavy.
DeleteI;ve heard great things about the Maybelleine product and I'm so keen to try it! My fav concealer so far is the Urban Decay Naked Skin one <3
ReplyDeletehttp://www.abigailalicex.com
It's a lovely concealer! I've heard lots about Naked Skin. I'd love to try that too!
DeleteI love the Maybelline because it doesn't crease when I apply it under my eyes, but I definitely have to use a foundation with a bit more coverage afterwards.
ReplyDeleteIt's brilliant that it doesn't crease but would be that much better if it wasn't quite so sheer!
DeleteYou can't beat the Collection concealer!
ReplyDeleteThe coverage is fab isn't it!
DeleteI LOVE the Collection one, so I'm sure I'd love the other two as well :) Your mixing sounds like a genius idea too!
ReplyDeleteClaire | Stylingo.co.uk
The Collection concealer has such great coverage! It works so well when teamed with others too!
DeleteCannot agree enough with Maybelline Instant Age Rewind! Since I've used it I honestly haven't even bothered trying anything else hahah x
ReplyDeleteKatina | www.katinalindaa.com
It's a great concealer, I wish that it had a little bit more coverage though!
DeleteI really want to try the Maybelline concealer since so many people rave about it, plus I love the applicator!
ReplyDeleteLauren Ashleigh xx
It's so lovely and hydrating, and the applicator makes is so easy for blending!
DeleteI really want to try the one from Rimmel, but I don't think it's available in the US :(
ReplyDeletePaula
Thirteen Thoughts
That's such a shame, the US normally seem to have everything ahead of us. Hopefully you'll get it soon!
DeleteI have not tried any of these!! I totally should!
ReplyDeleteXO JNESS
jenessasheffield
I definitely recommend all three. They're fab!
DeleteI love the collection lasting perfection concealer, it's such an amazing concealer and it's so cheap too which is a huge bonus xx
ReplyDeleteI love it when I come across a staple product that's really affordable. It makes it a lot easier to part with the money when repurchasing!
DeleteYour photos are just gorgeous! Love your blog. I've just repurchased the collection one for like the 100th time. It's just soo good for £5!!xx
ReplyDeleteThank you so much! It's a brilliant product, I'm always amazed how cheap it is!
DeleteI really want to try the Maybelline one!
ReplyDeleteKisses,
BLOG | Taislany
I definitely recommend it!
DeleteI love the Maybelline concealer and it's one of my favourite drugstore concealer. It jus covers imperfection so well. Xx
ReplyDeleteeLLa
every LiTTLE thing07
It's such a gorgeous formula. Maybelline have done so well!
DeleteI have the Rimmel Wake Me Up which is my fav. I also do have the Maybelline one but not my fav just ok.
ReplyDeletehttp://allornothing-blog.blogspot.co.uk/
Maybelline is quite sheer so I guess it depends how much coverage you're after!
DeleteCan I just say, these photos are great. So clean, so sharp. Also, Very interesting concept with mixing all the concealers :)
ReplyDeleteSamantha Series | bloglovin
Thank you so much! Mixing concealers is great, you get all the best qualities in one!
DeleteI love the Maybelline Eye Eraser :) so easy to blend, brightening and lightweight. I do have Wake Me Up, I will have to give it a proper go xx
ReplyDeleteJasmine Talks Beauty
Everything about it is brilliant. Defintiely worth getting the Rimmel concealer back out too :)
DeleteInitially, I was a fan of the Collection Lasting Perfection concealer. But as my dark circles worsened, I found that the concealer only made the area look ashy and dull. It just wasn't doing any justice. The shade options are also really limited. At the moment I'm using Maybelline's FIT ME which I find that it not only brightens the under-eye area, but its also great for covering up blemishes and discolouration! x
ReplyDeletePS- your photos are amazing!
bohorush.blogspot.com
I agree, it can look a little dull which I why I always use the other two concealers as a brightener but I find it has really great coverage! They definitely need to bring out more shades to suit a larger variety of skin tones though. I've heard good things about FIT ME so I'll have to give it a try! Thank you so much :)
DeleteI actually purchased the Eye Eraser a few weeks ago after seeing all the great reviews and I must admit I was a bit disappointed. Just like you said, it doesn't have much coverage .. but the Rimmel one looks promising, and perhaps that's the one I'll reach for next time I'm in the shop.
ReplyDeleteAlso, I absolutely loooove your name!
Ree xx // Coffee With Ree
Gorgeous clear photos! I too have ridiculous dark circles, so the collection lasting perfection is one of my favourites! Though it is rather thick. I also love the Rimmel lasting finish concealer, it has a peachy tone and a creamy consistency, so worn under a brighter concealer and I can really get a flawless finish ^_^
ReplyDeleteIqra | The Blushing Giraffe x